The Journal of Military History

Abstract

While studies of combat motivation once suggested that soldiers principally fought for their comrades, historians now argue that strong interpersonal bonds could not have survived the attrition of the two world wars. Research based on Second World War service records suggests otherwise, however. This article furthers this incipient revisionism by investigating how the composition of a Canadian wartime unit, the Seaforth Highlanders, changed across the war based on the battalion nominal roll and digitized service records. It argues that historians have fundamentally misunderstood the impact of casualties, as the continuity needed for unit cohesion to motivate soldiers did, in fact, persist. This article demonstrates that scholars must reassess the supposed inability of social groups to survive the modern battlefield.

Read the full article

Members: read on EBSCO

Use the access code from this quarter's member email. Every issue since 1937 is online, with no embargo.

Open on EBSCO

Lost your code? Email jmhsmh@vmi.edu or sign in at the EBSCOhost member login.

Not a member? Buy this article

A PDF sent by email from the Journal office during business hours, $10.

Order the PDF

Through a library: sign in with your institution

Full text is in EBSCO's America: History and Life with Full Text and Historical Abstracts with Full Text, and through EBSCO Discovery.

Institutional sign-in

Join: read everything, every year

Membership includes the printed journal and full online access to the archive.

Join the Society

Cite this article

Jake Gasson, “Rethinking Unit Cohesion in Modern War: The Case of the Seaforth Highlanders of Canada during the Second World War,” The Journal of Military History 90, no. 4 (October 2026): 922–952.

RISBibTeX

Also in Vol. 90, No. 4